4 Comments
User's avatar
The Glass Desk's avatar

The Nike case shows the gap: 24 raises and a 4.58% yield pass the screen while FCF missed the dividend. On ADP, $0.93 to $1.70 over five years is about 12.8% a year, so roughly 12.8 of its 15.4 Chowder comes from the backward-looking input. I'd rerun that growth number on the last two raises only.

Dave Ahern's avatar

If we look at NKE’s Chowder for the last 2 years, we see yield of 4.66% + 2-year growth of 2.5%, giving us 7.16, well below what you’d like to see. But that is to be expected in a struggling stock, right?

The Glass Desk's avatar

Yeah, that 7.16 is the point of the two-raise cut. The long lookback still clears NKE and the recent one fails it, so the screen already shows the break.

The Income Lair's avatar

I've been running my own version of this on my high-yield book, except the growth leg is usually negative. A fund paying 100% with NAV bleeding 60% scores great on the classic formula and terribly in real life. Do you ever flip the rule around and test it against total return, or is that stretching it past what it was built for?